NYtoNJ said:
Huntley Taverne in Summit (I checked - open on Mondays).
bookgirl said:
A Toute Heure is the best! I'm sure it's not open Mondays but you should definitely try it another time.
DaveSchmidt said:
We all had a great time tonight at Orange Squirrel, with my dad especially enthusiastic about the pan-seared whole bronzini. Just what we were looking for. Thanks again, @bak.

If anybody has gotten past such an insufferable list of particulars, I'd appreciate some ideas in the area. Including disabuse of any of my assumptions.
ETA: Thanks, all; my request has been fulfilled. But amandacat (see below) has an anniversary-related question, if anyone would like to address hers.